19 September 2012

The anti-Islam movie case: extremists at play



While watching an Al Jazeera documentary called “The 9/11 decade”, I was struck by what a former CIA official said to his interviewer: “basically Bin Laden said jump and Mr Bush and Mr Cheney said how high?” admitting that “we did exactly what they want it us to do by going to Afghanistan”. The leader of Al Qaeda and his mujahidin had already defeated the Soviet Union in Afghanistan in the 1980s and was only waiting for the United States to invade the country for it was certain that victory would be on their side once more. The attack on the Twin towers on 9/11 was meant to provoke just that: bring the United States to their battlefield. At the same time, right-wing anti-Muslim hardliners were able to gain the upper hand in the political debate and thereby influence US foreign policy.


The same pattern appears to be unfolding in the events that followed the publication of the trailer of the anti-Islam movie, Innocence of Muslims. The facts are well known. The movie provoked a wave of protest in front of US embassies of many Arab countries and the killing of the US ambassador to
Libya Chris Stevens and three members of his staff. If one looks at who is behind the movie, it is clear that this was meant to provoke these reactions and is part of an attempt to discredit the image of Islam, especially after the Arab uprisings had put islamophobic hardliners on the sidelines. Moreover, the timing, on the anniversary of 9/11 and just before the US presidential election, reveals an attempt to harden US foreign policy in the Middle East and to influence the upcoming presidential elections. In the words of Tariq Ramadan, “there are people from behind the scenes who are playing on symbols, emotional politics and pushing to something which is a clash”.

In the United States, the effects on the political debate have been felt. The events have been framed "within a narrative about politically immature Muslims who are forever intolerant of solemn Western values"[1]. A mainstream media like CNN got to the point of even questioning whether the Arab Spring was really worth it. Obama's foreign policy in the Middle East is under attack by those who condemned his support for protest movements (which is questionable) where it was clear that Islamic groups would come out strengthened, thereby losing the influence it had through its ties with dictators like Mubarak without gaining the support of the people. This is also likely to influence the upcoming US presidential elections, although Mitt Romney's attempt to exploit the events for campaign purposes may have backfired on him. 

In Arab countries, a good example of the impact of these demonstrations on domestic politics is the ambiguos response of the Egyptian president Mohammed Morsy, who initially said nothing to condemn the breach of the US embassy in Cairo, only to make a U-turn when president Obama said that he didn't consider Egypt an ally, although he didn't consider it an enemy either. The motivation behind Morsy's initial failure to immediately condemn the embassy's breach is best explained by Tariq Ramadan, for whom religious credibility is going to play an increasing role in the Muslim world today. Reacting in this way at what is said in the West about the prophet of Islam and claiming to be the only true guardians of Islam, Salafis are pushing the government to more hardline positions. 

So what we have here is the US anti-Islam far right and the ultra-religious far right in the Muslim world playing the same game: whipping up the clash of civilizations. As MoustafaBayoumi puts it, "what is really driving the current explosion is not really wounded religious sensibilities, or cultures of complaint, or atavistic Islamic rage. It is politics. And it is often a local politics of jockeying for power through mobilization of a religious base, whether in the United States or in Muslim-majority countries".




[1] http://www.merip.org/mero/interventions/men-behaving-badly

No comments:

Post a Comment